Patty Baker Humane Society Naples Blog
Nine Months, 1,629 Adoptions: Q3 2026 Update
One year ago this month, I began my journey as CEO here at Patty Baker Humane Society Naples. It’s been an amazing, challenging, and unbelievably fulfilling year. I’ve met an unbelievably warm and generous pet-loving community here in southwest Florida that wants their community shelter to be the absolute best. And so that’s what we’re trying to deliver. Because the one-year mark coincides with Q3’s end, I thought it might be a good time to share a bit of the story of where we were, where we are, and where we’re going.
On my very first day, I pulled a report to better understand how long animals were staying in our care. On that day, if you chose the median dog in our animal population, they had been here for six months. Specifically 176 days, waiting. Waiting. Thirty-one dogs had been here more than a year, and 14 of those had been here more than two. We had to do more.
Length of time in care is one of a few important industry metrics that help us understand how animals are moving through the shelter. Shelters, by their very nature, are temporary stops on a pet’s journey home. As much as we love and care for them, and do our very best to make their stay comfortable, shelters are not homes. We’re not a sanctuary. Our charge is to get them into the best possible home as quickly as we can. There are naps on couches that are just waiting for them to be had!
On October 6, my one-year anniversary, I pulled the same report. (Some people celebrate with cake. I celebrate with spreadsheets… and cake.) The change was, well… this. The same median dog in our care has now been here just 14 days. Meaning half our dog population has been here 14 days or less. A 92% drop. Sixty-five long stay (6 months or greater) adoptable pets were adopted over the past year. Fifteen pets who had been here for 2 years or more (!) found their families in the past year. In the last 365 days, we’ve helped 2,145 pets find homes.
There’s more, and I’ll come back to that. But first, the quarterly report.
Q3 By the Numbers
Here’s July 1 through September 30, compared with the same quarter last year:
-
-
- 97.25% save rate, up from 93.99% in Q3 2025
- 635 Q3 adoptions, up 28%
- 227 Q3 dog adoptions, up from 90 (152% more)
- 408 Q3 cat adoptions, up 7%
- 655 dog and cat intakes into our program, up 16%
- 548 transfers in from partner shelters, up 71%
- 221 of those from Collier County Domestic Animal Services, up 33%
- 18 non-live outcomes, down from 34
-
And year-to-date through the first nine months of 2026:
-
-
- 97.06% save rate, up from 95.19% at this point last year
- 1,629 adoptions, up 16%
- 657 dog adoptions, compared with 300 through September 2025
- 1,735 dog and cat intakes, up 11%
- 1,373 transfers in from partner shelters, up 35%
- 12,977 volunteer hours
-
More In, More Home
To start, I simply want to recognize the people who made it all happen. I am so proud of this team, our staff and volunteers, the community, our fosters and adopters. Together, we’ve had an unbelievable year of growth, and ALL of it to benefit the care and lives of the pets we work tirelessly for every day, no days off.
We took in more dogs and cats than last year, said yes to a significant number of additional transfers, made more families, all while our save rate went UP more than three points. And even with 16% more dogs and cats coming into care, non-live outcomes fell 47%. Summer in a Florida shelter means kitten season, hot summer days and full kennels. Basically, none of this happened during a quiet stretch. We didn’t slow down to make it easier, we pushed to do more.
Last quarter I told you dog adoptions had more than doubled. They did it again. 227 dogs went home in Q3, compared with 90 adoptions in the same three months last year. Through September we’ve adopted out 657 dogs, more than twice the 300 we’d placed at this point in 2025. And let’s not forget about cats! 408 cats were adopted in Q3, compared with 380 during the same quarter last year.
Our partner shelters are leaning on us more, too, and we want them to. We brought in 548 animals by transfer this quarter, 71% more than last summer, and 221 of them came from Collier County Domestic Animal Services. When our own county’s shelter needs room, we want to be the first call they make… and more and more often, we’re able to say yes.

Where the Long-Stay Dogs Went
Last quarter I joked that we were running out of five-year dogs to throw parties for. I was only half joking.
I mentioned this in the intro, but I want to dig in a little bit more here. That 176-day median isn’t an average being dragged up by a handful of extreme cases. It meant that half of the 95 dogs in our care on that day had already been here six months or longer. Forty-seven had crossed six months. Thirty-one had been here more than a year. Fourteen had been here more than two. Long stays needed our help.
So, we got started. As detailed at greater length in previous blogs, we scratch built our entire animal care process from the ground-up using Association of Shelter Veterinarians and ASPCA frameworks, consultations from UF Shelter Medicine/Maddie’s Fund, nationally-renowned behaviorist Kelley Bollen, a residency with Dogs Playing for Life, and guidance from partner shelters like Brother Wolf Animal Society in Asheville, KC Pet Project in Kansas City, and Halifax Humane in Daytona. The team rolled up their sleeves, we prioritized quality of care, we worked with urgency, and began daily population rounds creating individualized adoption plans for each and every pet. Why haven’t they been adopted? What are we doing today to get them adopted? And then the exact same thing tomorrow. We are open, we are transparent, and we are responsible to our pets and our community. No exceptions.
One year later, four dogs in our current population have been here more than 90 days.
They went home.
They went home. So far this year, 49 pets have been adopted after spending six months or longer with us. Twenty-eight of them had waited more than a year, including 14 who had waited more than two years.
This quarter, Queenie went home after 1,328 days. Gimli waited 1750. Maddy waited 554, Sasha 503, Harry 420, and Escobar 183. All of them are in homes now, likely on a couch somewhere taking that much-deserved and needed nap. Welcome home, babies.
Gimli is a great example. Gimli is one of those pups that the whole team was rooting for. He’s an enthusiastic, high-energy guy who just needed to find the right match for his specific needs. He had been in our program since November of 2021. Almost five full years. Shoutout to LaDonna and Heather for giving him a little break from the shelter earlier this year. A few weeks away from the noise and stress of shelter life did a world of good for him. But after 1750 days of waiting, early in September his dreams came true. We helped him with an individualized plan. He got the care and attention he needed. We got the information we needed to help. And he found his perfect match! Yay Gimli (seen above wearing glasses and a hat as the sophisticated boy he is)!
The long stay adoptables report I receive is beautifully short these days (and Gimli’s name is no longer on it). I’ll take it.
Faster, and the Matches Are Holding
A shorter stay is better quality of life, plain and simple. Pets belong in homes, not shelters. But to be clear for those who might still be confused, even after a year of all of these long stay adoptions, there is ABSOLUTELY no time limit at our shelter. But we will never be complacent. We will always act with urgency. Every day a dog doesn’t spend in a kennel is a day spent on a couch with their people.
Also, it’s important to note: moving faster only counts if the matches hold. Fast, but reckless or sloppy isn’t responsible, and it’s not an option for us. Through September, our adoption return rate dropped from 12.7% at this point last year to 9.9%, even as adoptions grew 16%. We’ve been under 10% every month since June, and September came in at 7.1%.
Sometimes a match feels like a good match, but it isn’t. It’s an animal shelter and with more than 2,000 pets coming through our doors annually, returns will happen.
But credit goes to the matching work. The playgroups we build and run every day tell us who a dog really is. The copious behavior notes our team now keeps add to that picture, and our daily population rounds and adoption plans make sure every animal has a plan and everyone is responsible for pushing it forward.

And they’re not all long stays, in fact there’s just not a lot of long stays left in our population. But that doesn’t make the job easier for the team. Bay came to us as a transfer from Animal Rescue Corps in late July. He was a sweet, sweet boy but he had been through some stress before getting to us and just wasn’t presenting well in the kennel. We took some time to work on him in playgroups. He had a nice little break in a foster home. And boom! By the end of September he had gone from shy and fearful to sleeping on his new couch at home.
We are saving lives. A 97.25% save rate (up from 95% over the same period of time in 2025) is a pretty clear indicator of that. But, 97% is not 100%. And you won’t find that little problematic two-word (no kill) phrase anywhere around here. We have a ton of goals around the shelter these days, but 100% save rate is not one of them. It’s neither practical nor responsible. While we were doing all of this work. While we were doing our absolute best to bring the absolute highest quality of care for our pets, we were also trying to educate an amazing pet-loving community about what an animal shelter is. Why they’re not sanctuaries. What safe means. What reasonable outcomes are (and why euthanasia is one of them). And ultimately, what it means to be a responsible humane society and caretaker of our most precious furry friends.
What’s changed at PBHSN?
Over the past year, there have been varying versions of the “what’s changed” question being asked. And every update report I’ve given over the past year has some version of “… and we’re not done yet” included. This report is no exception.
For a long time, the work here was a pet-loving team doing their absolute best to manage a backlog of dogs who’d waited so long to find their homes. Today the work is making sure that an operational foundation exists to sustain our lifesaving mission for generations to come.
And, I guess it’s important to note here as well. This is only the animal care part of our journey over the past year. There’s an entirely separate, equally comprehensive reinvention of our administrative processes and operations that I won’t even mention. We’re doing more, spending less, trying to operate more efficiently, balance our budget, and be responsible stewards of our support. There is no alternative, it’s non-negotiable for me.
One year in, so many more to go. And here’s your open invite from me personally… If you haven’t been to the shelter in a while, I want to personally invite you to come visit us. See it for yourself. It’s right here waiting for you to see and hear. Notice the shelter itself. See our kennels. Watch a playgroup. Visit with an adoptable.
I opened this blog with a bunch of thanks. I’m going to re-thank everyone again (because it’s my already-too-long blog and I want to)! Thank you to this unbelievably hard working team of staff members, our board, volunteers, and fosters, who were open to trying new things with the promise that it would help save more lives. Thank you to everyone who when met with a challenge, embraced it as an opportunity. Our volunteers have given us nearly 13,000 hours this year. Our fosters keep opening their homes, and our transfer partners keep trusting us with their animals. Every adopter, donor and supporter who shared a post or cheered us on helped build these numbers.
And thank you to our generous supporters who help fund our life-saving work. As a gift-based, 501c3 nonprofit organization, Patty Baker Humane Society Naples cannot do anything that we do without your support. If you believe in our mission and want to help us go further and do more, please consider making a contribution of support.
We’re not done yet. On to Q4!